Dear George
It is my opinion that you are entitled to do to your films what you see fit. They are yours and if you feel that they do not adequately fulfil your vision for their respective stories, and you are able to do something about it, then, by all means, please tinker and tweak to your hearts content. As someone who wrestles with the outcome of creative ability constantly, I fully understand your desire to reshape your films. If this allows future generations to be amazed by what they’re seeing on screen, then I can’t think of a possible problem with that.
What I would love to ask, however, is to please try and appease those who were inspired by a different version of your films. I will not say ‘better’ or ‘worse’ versions: those words are highly subjective and cannot be used in this situation. The only word that can describe these earlier versions is ‘different’.
There are millions of people around the world who were inspired by earlier versions of your films. We know the beat of the films, we know the flow and we were amazed and delighted by these versions. These versions, I imagine, pushed many of those people into successful film careers (or burgeoning), and influenced their work to this very day. They are versions that, while they may not be your ultimate editions, are so deeply embedded and ingrained in our subconsciousness and soul that they almost become second nature.
We are deeply humbled by these films.
We can only ask that they be preserved, along with your intended editions of the films, so that we can carry this wonderful time capsule with us into our careers and our futures. There’s room in the world for all of us to be happy.
Sincerely
Anthony J. Scarcella